The Central Park Manhattan House – Decision Review
The Central Park Manhattan House is a rental apartment building in New York City’s Upper West Side (10025). It offers one‑bedroom apartments with monthly rents between USD 1,990 and USD 2,250. The property has a Google rating of 3.8 from 60 reviews, and its own rating dimensions highlight very high scores for location, social atmosphere, amenities, community, ease of getting around, and value for money (all 5.0). On‑site features include a gym, laundry facility, and BBQ grill. The deposit is USD 1,990 (equal to one month’s rent at the lower end). Below is a detailed look at who this residence works for, who might prefer alternatives, what actual residents say, and how it compares with the city’s general rental market.
All prices are indicative — confirm with the operator.
Location & Neighborhood
The address is New York, NY 10025, USA — the Upper West Side near Central Park. Residents report walking distance to Central Park, subway access, grocery stores, and cafes. The location rating is 5.0, and the “getting around” score is also 5.0. This suggests the building is well‑connected for daily life and commuting. The neighborhood is residential but vibrant, with ample amenities within a short walk.
Who It Suits
The Central Park Manhattan House works best for tenants who:
- Value a central Upper West Side location – If you want to be near Central Park for recreation, have easy subway access, and prefer a walkable neighbourhood with shops and cafes, this property’s location is a strong fit.
- Want a private one‑bedroom apartment – The unit type listed is “1b” (one‑bedroom) and “apartment,” so you get your own separate living space, kitchenette or full kitchen, and bathroom. This suits individuals or couples who need more privacy than a shared dorm or studio.
- Appreciate on‑site fitness and BBQ – A gym, laundry facility, and BBQ grill are included. If you use a gym regularly and enjoy outdoor cooking, these amenities add convenience.
- Prioritise social atmosphere – The social dimension score is 5.0, and community and amenities also score 5.0. This indicates a strong sense of community among residents, possibly driven by shared spaces or events. Someone looking for a place with friendly neighbours and an active social life will likely feel at home.
- Are comfortable with a monthly rent around USD 2,000+ – The price range is above the city’s overall from‑price of USD 850 (which likely reflects shared rooms or far‑outer borough options). For a private one‑bedroom in a prime Upper West Side location, this range is typical.
Who Should Look Elsewhere
This residence may not be right for you if:
- You have a tight budget – At USD 1,990–2,250 per month, it is significantly above New York City’s general entry‑level rentals (from USD 850). Students or early‑career workers on a shoestring budget would find cheaper options in shared apartments or farther neighbourhoods.
- You expect pristine cleanliness and pest‑free conditions – One Google review (1 star) describes a mouse incident. While management’s response was blamed on the tenant, the review suggests that pest issues may occur and that resolution might not be prompt. Another review praises cleaning staff, but the negative review is worth noting if you have zero tolerance for rodents.
- You need a short‑term rental or flexible lease – The minimum lease length is listed as “null” (not provided). You must confirm with the operator whether they accept month‑to‑month or only year‑long leases.
- You prefer a no‑frills, low‑community environment – With social and community scores of 5.0, the building likely organises or encourages resident interaction. If you want complete anonymity and quiet, this may feel intrusive.
What Residents Actually Say
Quotes from Google reviews (verbatim):
Harry Wu (5 stars): “The weekly cleaner named Maria is a super nice person, she works hard and done cleaning very well. I love her style of service and this is one of the most thing I love when I live here.”
KoKi Top (1 star): “At first I loved it great place to crash had to stay in new york for a while. I woke up one morning to find a mouse digging through my trash it jumped out and ran under the fridge. I killed it, told them about it and they blamed me of course wasn’t surprised. Since no one did anything about i took care of it myself fou”
Vin Vin (5 stars): “Stayed few nights with friend, had room with own bathroom and kitchenette area. Great place to stay, plus having subway acsess, grocer, cafe and Central Park all right there in little walking distance. Definitely would stay time and time again.”
Key takeaways:
- Positive comments highlight the location’s convenience, the friendly weekly cleaner, and the private setup with kitchenette.
- The single negative review points to a mouse problem and poor management response. This is a serious concern; however, the overall rating (3.8) suggests that most guests had a satisfactory experience.
- The property’s own rating dimensions show lower scores (around 3.5 to 3.8) for food, staff, accuracy, cleaning, internet, condition, management, indoor spaces, room experience, safety/security, study environment, and property maintenance — so while location and social aspects shine, other operational areas are only average.
Price & Value
New York City’s from‑price for student housing (across 212 properties) is USD 850 per month. That low figure typically represents a shared room or a dorm‑style unit in outer boroughs. The Central Park Manhattan House charges USD 1,990–2,250 for a private one‑bedroom apartment in Manhattan’s Upper West Side. That places it squarely in the mid‑to‑upper range for a solo rental.
Value proposition: For someone who can afford it, the trade‑off is a superb location, private space, and on‑site amenities in exchange for a rent that is roughly 2.4 times the city’s baseline. If you need a budget option, this is not it. But if you want convenience and a degree of comfort, the community and location scores (both 5.0) suggest residents feel the price is fair.
All prices are indicative — confirm with the operator.
Room Type Guidance
The only unit type listed is “1b” (one‑bedroom) and “apartment.” This means you get a separate bedroom, a living area, and likely a kitchenette (as one reviewer mentions) or full kitchen. There is no shared dormitory option. The apartments are probably self‑contained, with your own bathroom. If you need a studio or a larger two‑bedroom, you would need to check with the operator whether those are available (the data suggests not).
For a single tenant or a couple, a one‑bedroom offers privacy. For groups wanting to share, this property may not have suitable units.
Booking Timing
No specific availability date was provided. For student housing in New York City, popular buildings often fill up 3–6 months before the academic semester (July/August for fall start). Since this property has only one‑bedroom apartments (not large dorm‑style blocks), availability may be more limited and more dependent on lease end dates. It is advisable to inquire at least 4–5 months ahead of your intended move‑in, and to confirm current availability with the operator.
FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions)
H3: Is the security deposit refundable?
The deposit is listed as USD 1,990. Terms are not provided in the data. You must confirm with the operator whether the full amount is refundable at move‑out, what deductions may apply, and whether it is returned within a standard timeframe (e.g., 30 days).
H3: Are utilities included in the monthly rent?
The data does not specify whether electricity, gas, water, or internet are included. One review mentions internet scored 3.5, which suggests that internet is provided but may vary in quality. Ask the operator for a full list of included utilities and any caps or extra charges.
H3: Can I have a pet in the apartment?
Pet policy is not mentioned. The building has a BBQ grill and outdoor space, but no explicit pet‑friendly tag. Contact the operator to confirm if cats or dogs are allowed, and if there are restrictions on size or breed.
Sources & Data Date
- Data extracted from the property listing on 2026‑07.
- Reviews sourced from Google (verbatim as written by users).
- City price reference (USD 850 from‑price) based on the market snapshot for New York City student housing (212 properties, 2026 data).
All prices, availability, and policies are indicative — confirm with the operator.
For live availability and specific move‑in dates, please use the on‑site assistant on the property page.
See also: listing details · browse more