An Overview of Cayuga Lofts
Cayuga Lofts is a rental property located in Ithaca, New York, at the address Ithaca, NY 14850, USA. It sits within a city that hosts a major university, and the property’s unit types include studios, one-bedroom, two-bedroom, and general apartments. The monthly rent spans from $1,585 to $3,169 (indicative — confirm with the operator). For context, the lowest available student housing price in Ithaca is $955 per month, so Cayuga Lofts occupies the higher end of the local market.
The building provides a gym, allows pets, and offers laundry facilities. On Google, it holds a rating of 4.1 out of 5 from 20 reviews. Below we break down who this residence suits, what residents actually say, price positioning, room-type guidance, and booking timing – all based on the available data as of July 2026.
Who Should Consider Cayuga Lofts?
Cayuga Lofts is best suited for students or renters who prioritise on-site amenities like a gym and pet-friendly policies, and who can afford a monthly rent significantly above the city’s baseline. The presence of a fitness centre and laundry facility means residents do not need to seek external services for these needs, which can be convenient for those without a car or with a packed schedule.
The property also appeals to renters who value proximity to the main university campus. Ithaca’s housing market is tight, and many students look for places within walking or short-commute distance. While the reviews indicate mixed experiences with management, the positive comments highlight a helpful leasing manager during the tour process and responsive maintenance. If you are willing to accept that an older building may have occasional repair needs but that the maintenance team typically addresses them quickly, Cayuga Lofts could be a workable option.
Conversely, this residence may not suit budget-conscious students who can find other options in Ithaca at the $955 price point. The gap of more than $600 per month for the cheapest unit at Cayuga Lofts is substantial. Renters who require a flawless management experience may also want to look elsewhere, given the one-star review that describes a deteriorating situation after a promising start. The property’s age (mentioned in a positive review) could be a drawback for those expecting brand-new finishes.
What Residents Actually Say
The three Google reviews provided give a window into the range of experiences at Cayuga Lofts. Here they are quoted verbatim:
5-star review by Haofei Cao:
“Dallyce is super nice and thoughtful. She showed me all the available room types I was interested in and gave me a very detailed virtual tour from Cayuga Place to Cayuga Lofts, even on a rainy day. Her tour really helped me make the decision to choose Cayuga Place for the coming year. I’m really looking forward to livi”
1-star review by Sanjana Sambur:
“I am changing my review to 1 star (wishing I could give 0). Our experience started off great thanks to Dallyce, she is an amazing manager and gave us a great tour. However, everything went downhill from there. I can no longer recommend this apartment complex to future renters. The disconnect between the local managemen”
5-star review by Christy Que:
“I enjoyed my time at Cayuga Place! The building is definitely older, and as expected with age, things tend to break fairly often. However, the maintenance team was always quick to respond and helpful whenever issues came up, which made these inconveniences manageable. The management office staff were approachable and s”
(Note: the texts appear truncated in the source data; they are reproduced exactly as provided.)
These comments collectively suggest that the initial impression – especially through Dallyce – is often positive, but ongoing experience can vary. The 1-star review indicates a breakdown in communication or service after moving in. The other 5-star review acknowledges the building’s age but praises maintenance responsiveness. Prospective renters should weigh the likelihood of needing maintenance against the quick service described. The property’s overall Google rating of 4.1 from 20 reviews suggests that the majority of reviewers have had satisfactory experiences, but the single negative review is pointed enough to warrant attention.
Price Positioning and Room Types
Ithaca’s city-level minimum student housing price is $955 per month. Cayuga Lofts’ minimum of $1,585 is 66% above that floor. The maximum of $3,169 is more than three times the city minimum. This positions Cayuga Lofts as a premium offering within the local market, likely due to its amenities (gym, pet-friendliness, laundry) and location relative to the university.
The available unit types are:
- Studio
- One-bedroom (1b)
- Two-bedroom (2b)
- Apartment (generic)
The exact pricing per unit type is not specified in the data, but generally studios and one-bedroom units would be at the lower end of the range, while larger apartments cost more. Given that the price span is quite wide (more than $1,500), the property likely has a mix of small and large floor plans. Pet-friendly terms are not detailed, so interested renters should confirm any additional fees or deposits with the operator.
For comparison, other properties in Ithaca may offer basic amenities at lower prices. If you need a gym or have a pet, however, Cayuga Lofts could justify the higher rent because those features are less common in budget-oriented student housing.
Booking Timing and Availability
Ithaca’s student housing cycle typically follows the academic calendar. For the 2026–2027 academic year, many units become available starting in the spring 2026, with leases beginning in August or September. By July 2026 (the date of this data), most prime units may already be taken. However, availability can fluctuate due to last-minute cancellations or re-listings.
It is advisable to start looking as early as possible – ideally six to eight months before your intended move-in date – to have a wider choice of floor plans and price points. If you are targeting a move-in for fall 2027, begin your search in early 2027. The property’s management office may offer virtual tours, as noted in the positive review. Given that only 20 Google reviews exist, the property does not have a huge online footprint, so contacting the operator directly for current availability and lease terms is essential. All prices are indicative and must be confirmed with the operator.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cayuga Lofts close to Cornell University?
The property is located in Ithaca, NY, and the city is home to Cornell University. While the exact distance is not provided in the data, its address in Ithaca places it within the general vicinity of the campus. Many Ithaca student accommodations are within walking distance or a short bus ride. It is best to check the specific location on a map and confirm commute options with the operator.
Are utilities included in the rent?
The data does not specify whether utilities are included. The rent range of $1,585–$3,169 per month is for the unit itself. You must clarify with the operator what is covered (e.g., water, electricity, internet) and any additional charges. The same applies to parking, storage, and pet fees.
How reliable is the management and maintenance?
Based on the reviews, the manager Dallyce is praised for being helpful and personable during tours and the leasing process. One positive review states the maintenance team is “quick to respond and helpful.” However, a separate review reports a “disconnect between the local management” and a decline in service after move-in. You should request a current tenant’s perspective if possible, or read more recent Google reviews (as of July 2026, there are 20 total). The overall 4.1 rating suggests that most residents have acceptable experiences, but individual results may vary.
Sources & data date: 2026-07
For live availability and current rates, use the on-site assistant on this page.
See also: listing details · browse more